Archives

GRAND GENÈVE ET SON SOL
A Charter for the Socio-Ecological Transition of a Cross-Border Metropolitan Region, 2018-2020
The city of Geneva and its region have always represented a diverse territory of perceived opposites – the Swiss-French, the protestant-catholic, international-local, and urban-rural qualities and conditions, all come together in the Genevian cuvette, framed by the Jura and the Alps. Today, the region encounters profound development challenge with fast population increase and strong housing demands projected to continue in the future. Since decades, the city has been spilling across the national border. Urban growth and land consumption in the Canton and in the French part of the Genevian agglomeration continue to put pressure on settlement areas and to erode agricultural and natural landscapes.

CONSULTATION GRAND GENÈVE 2050
Already in 2008, the French and Swiss municipalities around Geneva formalised a decade-long process of negotiating regional cooperation and planning by creating a new territorial entity, the Grand Genève. Ten years later, in October 2018, the public Consultation Grand Genève 2050 launched by the Fondation Braillard Architectes, gathered seven international and interdisciplinary teams around a task to propose design and planning visions for the future of Grand Genève, based on the necessity of “ecological transition” and in line with the principles of sustainable development. Further, the competition brief asked to offer design and planning strategies, not only for the city of Geneva, but for the entire region to combat the resulting increasing social injustice.

In this framework, the team of the ETH Zürich Architecture of Territory, the UNI Luxembourg Master in Architecture, and Raumbureau A+U elaborated Grand Genève et son sol, a territorial strategy for a more self-sufficient and polycentric cross-border region.

We asked our self; how design can help to mediate among different cross-border interests, governance arrangements and thus assist transboundary solutions? How to set a common vision and project for the region, which operated beyond the city-centric conceptions, and beyond the national border? And further, could a new regional planning approach respond to the urgency of social and environmental “transitions”, facing up to the climate crisis and biodiversity loss?

BRINGING THE LAND BACK INTO THE CITY
Our prospect for Greater Geneva approaches the urgency of socio-ecological transition through the problematic of land, understood in its manifold expressions – as an ecological structure, as appropriated and regulated territory, and as a symbolic landscape of specific places and identities. The central hypothesis is that the currently asymmetric region should be transformed into more equitable, ecologically balanced and polycentric city-landscape, in which the built and the unbuilt environments, in all their diversity, are productively interwoven. Herein, a successful transborder governance will be crucial.
We envision a determined effort toward a new deal for socio-ecological transition based on the overhaul of the current property and governance arrangements on all levels through the idea of commons: from individualism and rentiership in agriculture, real- estate, transport and other urban domains, toward the development and promotion of common and cooperative governance arrangements and models. The prospect for Greater Geneva is organised in the form of a Charter which operates along two axes. The first axis elaborates five sets of urban strategies: Cité naturelle addressing the protection of nature areas and resources; Cité agricole promoting regionalisation of food system on the principles of agroecology; Cité de proximité elaborating strategies for the decentralisation of services and working opportunities across the region; Cité partagée setting precedents for new communal and collective practices; and Cité cyclique setting out approaches to circularity of material and energy flows. These urban strategies can be deployed at various scales, from regional and urban to architectural.

The second axis of the Charter describes seven territories of potentials in the region, that should serve as basis for future land-use decisions. The built-up and the unbuilt lands throughout the region ought to be harmonised with each other, and any further competition among land uses avoided. The reframing of the land use questions tackles specific potentials and problems of Greater Geneva, from regeneration and retrofitting of obsolete fossil infrastructures to the loss of valuable agricultural land to construction, particularly in French Geneva. The seven territories of potentials are: Bi-national metropolis, Global-local territories, Post-fossil infrastructures, Agri-landscape rooms, Metropolitan countryside, Vital streams and canopies, and Mountain parks. Derived from numerous fieldwork expeditions with students in the region since 2016, the territories of potentials have been elaborated through urbanistic and cartographic analysis and synthesis. The Charter also offers a programmatic outline with agendas for design and governance at various scales, and over thirty design case studies for various sites across the region. Thus, a new urban figure, which balances social and environmental needs and qualities, becomes possible. The new urban figure – in effect, a new kind of city-landscape which emerges at regional scale – dissolves the centre-periphery dichotomy, giving shape to a more equitable, polycentric, self-sufficient and regenerative landscape. In contrast to a master plan, the proposed territorial strategies are flexible, and able to respond to various and unpredictable scenarios of growth and shrinkage. While the external boundaries of the future city-region would be demarcated by the silhouette of the cuvette genevoise, its development would take place internally, within the figure. In a continuous dialogue among citizens, administrations, political bodies, international institutions such as the UN and CERN, and representatives of the economy and civic movements, the strategies of the Charter can be spatialised and concretised, making Greater Geneva a European frontrunner in becoming a sustainable, emission-free and resilient metropolis.

The Consultation Grand Genève 2050 concluded in September 2020 with a final dialogue. Since, the project has been further presented in a TV documentary, in public lectures, in conferences and newspaper articles.

 

PROJECT TEAM
Grand Genève et son sol: A Charter for the Socio-Ecological Transition of a Cross-Border Metropolitan Region, September 2020.

ETH Zürich DARCH, Chair of Architecture and Territorial Planning
Prof. Milica Topalović
Karoline Kostka
Muriz Djurdjevic
Ferdinand Pappenheim
Charlotte Schaeben
Jan Westerheide

University of Luxembourg FHSE, Master in Architecture
Prof. Dr Florian Hertweck
Prof. Dr Markus Hesse
Prof. Dr Nikos Katsikis
Ivonne Weichold

Raumbureau A+U
Rolf Jenni
Tom Weiss

EXPERTS
Dr Philippe Brun, Dr Thomas Gibon, Prof. Dr Tanja Herdt, Prof. Dr Christoph Küffer, Dr Elena Cogato Lanza, Peter Loosli, Dr Antonino Marvuglia, Prof. Dr Francesco Viti

Knowledge gained through the work with students in the Geneva region since the fall semester of 2016 greatly informed the project. It was possible to gain a comprehensive understanding of the region by means of multiple cycles of design and research studios, field trips, elective courses, and two free diploma projects at ETH Zürich DARCH Architecture of Territory and UNI Luxembourg FHSE Master in Architecture. Student work and participation greatly enriched the project’s research and design.

We would like to thank all of the collaborators, experts, students, and friends who contributed their invaluable support to the project.

SELECTED DESIGN AND RESEARCH STUDIO
Metropolitan Countryside — Lac Léman
Communes — Le Village Suisse Revisited
Geneva Unbuilt (1/2) — Gardening City and Land
Geneva Unbuilt (2/2) — Ideas take Root

CONTACT
Karoline Kostka
kostka@arch.ethz.ch

 

CALL
Consultation Grand Genève 2050
Fondation Braillard Architectes
October 2018

PRESENTATIONS AND TALKS
Final dialogue Consultation Grand Genève 2050
Final presentation ‘Grand Genève et son sol’

23 September 2020

Conference cycle ‘Designing the transition of Greater Geneva’
Presentations ‘Soil as common project
with Florian Hertweck and Paola Viganò
04 February 2021

Presentations ‘Metropolitan forms and constellations
with Milica Topalović and Stefano Boeri
06 May 2021

PRESS
‘Seven prospective visions for Greater Geneva’, in Bâtisseurs suisses – projects, June 2021.
‘La ville durable – Sept visions pour le Grand Genève’, LemanbleuTV documentary, February 2021.
‘Possibilities for Ecological Transition in Geneva’ in Newsletter NSL – Netzwerk Stadt und Landschaft, ETH Zürich, December 2020.
Consultation Grand Genève. Som­mes-nous prêts pour la tran­si­ti­on?, in TRACÉS, November 2020.

PUBLICATION
Forthcoming